Jonathan Melikidse at 2014-10-03 15:07:15:
Agree this ranks at the top of Tarantino's best character exchanges. There are a couple reasons I feel this scene works so well. First, it's the suspense of the scene. We know what is going to happen. We know Mr. Worley is going to die. He knows it too. Hitchcock once said, "Suspense can only be achieved by telling the audience as much as you can." Coccotti tells him at the start of their conversation, " You tell the angels in Heaven you never seen evil so singularily personified as you did in the face of the man who killed you." This is all the information we need to know to put us in an immediate state of sympathy for Mr. Worley. The next thing that happens that makes this even better is we have to wait. 10 minutes, we have to wait! This is a master class in dulling out the ineveitable while keeping us tremendously entertained. Not only is it two amazing actors playing off eachother, it's engaging dialogue. Coccotti wants the truth. Mr. Worley wants to protect his son. So what does he do? He spends the next few minutes insulting the man who is about to kill him instead of giving him what he wants. Forcing Coccotti to kill him quickly as opposed to beating the information out of him.
The other bit that really makes this scene work is the pacing. Conversation > Punch in the nose> Conversation> cuts his hand > Story about truth, final threat > Gives him a cigarette >Mr. Worley's resignation> everyone laughs> Coccotti shoots Mr. Worley.
Then the real punchline of it all... the answer to Coccotti's question was pinned to the fridge.