> “Make your
audience entirely clear upon the character of each person in the story”
> ...When you introduce a character, you have the right to approach it in a more ‘novelistic’ way. ...Providing the
reader a thumbnail sketch of a character’s persona is an effective way of making it “entirely clear” who each character is.
[bolding added]
I wonder about this a lot, and wrestle with it in my writing. I wonder if the two quotes above (from Loos, then Scott) aren't talking about two different things--related things, but different things.
Loos is talking about making an impression on the audience, but a "novelistic" description is by definition going to make an impression only on the script reader, not the film viewer. (or am I missing something here?)
I think the sweet spot probably lies in recognizing that, in the case of a spec script, you need to communicate to both "constitutencies": a busy slushpile reader needs to "get it" when they rush through your script, AND what you write needs to translate into a clear and meaningful character introduction for a theatre audience watching the finished product.
My gut feeling is that writing for an audience will, in most cases, also serve a reader, but writing with just a reader in mind may not always serve an audience. In other words, if you err, err to the side of the audience, but realize that a reader has a different perspective and different needs (see also: spelling out moments in dialogue for a spec that can be conveyed with a look on film, etc.).
. . .
Back to introducing a primary character: Has anyone here read the Aaron Sorkin pilot for West Wing? The introduction of President Jed Bartlett is magnificent. It's the gold standard for me of powerful and effective character introductions.
Here's a link to the PDF at Daily Scripts:
West Wing Pilot [pdf]. (If you haven't read it, grab it while it's available and give yourself a treat.)
. . .
PS Thank you Scott for the Anita Loos series and the link to the book. I read the book when you first posted about it and really enjoyed it, and I'm enjoying the series as well.