Garrett York at 2012-02-15 15:49:20:
I don't know that I agree with how successful Chronicle was, at least from audience perspective. Or more specifically, my perspective. I thought the set-up for the main camera was far too convenient, almost throw-away to get the story started. And the gimmicky cell-phone scene mixed with a plethora of security cameras and police dash-cams made the whole ending battle so aware of itself that I couldn't help but think about how I was sitting in a movie theatre watching this movie with my friends. There was almost no emotional attachment at that point.
Now, I'm usually the resident "snob" in my group of friends, but all of them agreed with me on the point. It felt contrived, and gimmicky. And the entire movie, all I could think of were ways I would've written things to make it more believable, and how if it hadn't been FF, it could've been so great. SO great. Not to mention every aspect of the characters, teen culture, and relationships felt so cliche, it must've been written by the child of some famous hollywood Director/Producer. Oh wait...
I just honestly don't see any of this happening with an outsider. They might think the attempt is cute, but not cute enough, even if you throw in a buzzword or two about found footage.
The bottom line is, it doesn't matter what I think. They made plenty of money back from their relatively small investment, and Max Landis gets to go on being Mr. Hollywood. Congrats!